“There’s No Such Thing As an Original Sin”

Welcome back, sinners! Elvis Costello is right, as usual, but he’s referring to “actual” sins — which are finite — not Original Sin, which is not our fault. Or is it?

So what does the man who explained it actually say about Original Sin in his City of God? Thanks for asking.

Augustine is usually thought to have invented the idea, which has come to embody everything that’s wrong with religion to the modern mind: petty doctrines, pointless guilt, fear and mind control. Bad Augustine!

But of course, he didn’t really invent it, and it’s not what people think. He builds on Paul’s Romans 5:12f and 1 Corinthians 15, Irenaeus, his teacher Ambrose, Justin Martyr, Tertullian, Cyprian and others. Irenaeus — the church’s first professional heresy hunter — said Adam was a big baby whose fruit-eating fit made God mad but doesn’t seem to be genetic. “In the person of the first Adam we offended God, disobeying his precept” (Heresies V:xvi:3).

Our old friend Tertullian had more to say, inventing an idea called Traducianism, which claims human souls are physically located in our DNA and are inherited. (An opposing school that used to be called Creationism — not modern Creationism — held souls are injected by God at conception.) Adam’s sin corrupted his physical soul-body, and as all of our great-great-yadda-yadda-yadda-fathers, he literally passed it along to us, so that “that which is from God is rather obscured than extinguished” (De Anima 41).

Augustine also inherited the notion in ancient biology that all future offspring were microscopically present in their ancestors. So purely as a scientist, he believed that (a) all of us were microscopically present body and soul in our ancestor Adam, and (b) when Adam sinned we were all LITERALLY there!

Thus, we really are all guilty in some way and truly deserve God’s punishment: two kinds of death, physical and spiritual. “No one prior to Augustine had so thoroughly depicted the sinful complicity of all humanity with Adam,” says Daniel L. Akin in A Theology for the Church.

Now, all of this is old genetics and not that important to the Big Question: Why did Adam and Eve disobey God in the first place?

Augustine takes this head-on in Book XIII. Delicious.


One response to ““There’s No Such Thing As an Original Sin”

  1. becoming conscious

    Genesis to me is a drama. Very much myth and metaphorical but equally trueand profound. In the garden there were no seperate trees, one for sin (evil) and another for sinless ( good) A and E tasted not just the bad (sin) one but also a lot more good. There was not only original sin, there was also original good as well. Withoutthis knowledge how can any one love another ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s